Owners Not Paying Levies in South Africa: Every Recovery Route a Body Corporate Has

Every sectional title scheme in South Africa has at least one. The owner who pays late, then partially, then not at all. Trustees send reminders. The managing agent adds interest. Eighteen months later the arrears sit at R80,000, the scheme has deferred its roof repairs, and the paying owners are quietly subsidising someone who has decided the levy is optional. At Jonker Vorster Attorneys we have seen that pattern repeat in schemes across the country for more than two decades.

It is not optional. But the route from “this owner owes us money” to “this money is in the scheme’s bank account” is more technical than most trustees realise, and the schemes that recover well are the ones that get the unglamorous procedural steps right at the start.

Here is what actually works.

Non-payment is a legal problem, not a cash flow problem

Trustees tend to treat arrear levies as a budgeting issue, a gap to be managed until the owner catches up. That framing costs schemes money, for three reasons.

First, the body corporate has a statutory duty to collect. The Sectional Titles Schemes Management Act 8 of 2011 (STSMA) obliges the body corporate to establish a fund sufficient to cover its expenses and to require owners to make contributions to it. Trustees who let arrears run are not being lenient; they are failing a function the Act places on them.

Second, every month of delay makes recovery harder. Debt prescribes. Owners sell up and disappear. Bonds get called up and the bank’s claim ranks ahead of yours in the free residue.

Third, and most practically: the paying owners fund the shortfall. A scheme that carries R200,000 in arrears has effectively levied that amount on the members who do pay.

Step 1: Make sure your levies are lawfully raised

This is where a surprising number of claims fall over. Before a body corporate can enforce a levy, it must be able to show the levy was properly raised.

That means:

  • A valid budget and resolution. Contributions must be based on a budget approved at a general meeting, with each owner’s share calculated according to participation quota unless the rules provide otherwise.
  • Proper notification under PMR 25(1). Prescribed Management Rule 25(1) requires the body corporate to notify owners in writing of the contributions due, the amounts, the due dates, and the interest rate that will apply to overdue amounts. An owner who was never properly notified has an obvious defence.
  • A lawful interest rate. PMR 21(3)(c) permits interest on overdue amounts at a rate specified in the scheme’s rules, but that rate may not exceed the maximum permitted under the National Credit Act of 2005. Schemes that inherited an old rule charging 2% per month should have it checked.

If the paperwork behind the levy is shaky, fix it before you send anything to attorneys. A defended matter that turns on whether the levy was validly raised is an expensive way to discover your minute book is thin.

Step 2: The PMR 25 final notice, do not skip this

Prescribed Management Rule 25(2) sets out what happens when contributions fall overdue. The body corporate must send the owner a final notice, and that notice must state the amount owing, the interest accruing, and that the body corporate intends to take action to recover the amount if it is not paid within 14 days of the notice being given.

Whether non-compliance with PMR 25 is fatal to a claim has been argued both ways. In Body Corporate of Kleber v Sehube (Gauteng Local Division, case 2021/A3094, 11 November 2021) the court held that compliance with regulation 25(1) and (2) does not need to be pleaded to sustain a cause of action. Writing in De Rebus, Anton Myburgh disagreed, arguing these are procedural prerequisites to instituting proceedings and that practitioners should comply and plead compliance “to be on the safe side.”

The practical position for trustees is simple: send the notice, keep proof of delivery, and give the full 14 days. It costs nothing and removes an argument the defaulting owner would otherwise get for free. We run this stage through Jumping Fox Software, the debtor management platform our directors co-founded, so pre-legal compliance is already in place by the time summons is issued.

Step 3: The letter of demand

Once the 14 days have run, a formal letter of demand from an attorney is the last cheap step. In a meaningful proportion of matters it is also the last step, because the arrival of a law firm’s letterhead changes the owner’s assessment of whether this will go away.

A letter of demand in a levy matter should set out:

  • The owner’s full name, unit number and scheme name
  • A breakdown of the debt: capital contributions, special levies, interest to date, and legal costs incurred so far
  • The daily interest rate, so the amount is capable of being calculated forward
  • The trustee resolution authorising the recovery
  • A payment deadline, usually 7 or 10 business days
  • A clear statement of what follows non-payment: summons, judgment, costs, and a credit bureau listing
  • The body corporate’s domicilium and banking details

One point trustees consistently undersell: PMR 25(4) makes the member liable for all reasonable legal costs and disbursements incurred in collecting arrear contributions. Say so in the letter. Owners who believe the scheme will absorb the legal costs behave very differently from owners who understand the costs are being added to their account.

Step 4: CSOS or court?

This is the decision that determines how long recovery takes, and it is the one most schemes get wrong.

The Community Schemes Ombud Service (CSOS) was created under the Community Schemes Ombud Service Act 9 of 2011 to give community schemes a cheap, accessible dispute forum. The application fee is nominal. For certain disputes it is genuinely the right tool.

For arrear levies with real value attached, it usually is not. Four reasons:

  1. Backlogs. CSOS has a small number of adjudicators handling a national caseload, reporting has put it at roughly four adjudicators carrying over 450 matters each. Adjudication on a levy dispute routinely runs past twelve months.
  2. No costs orders. Adjudicators rarely award costs against the losing party. A scheme that wins at CSOS still carries its own legal spend, which defeats the point of PMR 25(4).
  3. No urgent relief. CSOS cannot grant urgent interim relief or interdicts. If you need to act quickly, it is the wrong forum.
  4. Enforcement is a second process. A CSOS adjudication order is not self-executing. Under section 56 of the CSOS Act it must be lodged with the clerk of the magistrate’s court and registered before the sheriff can do anything with it. You win, and then you start again.

Our position at Jonker Vorster Attorneys, having worked with bodies corporate since 2002, is that CSOS is a tool worth using when it is genuinely the right tool for the dispute, a conduct rule argument, a records access complaint, a scheme governance question. For arrear levies where the scheme needs the money and needs its costs back, the Magistrate’s Court is normally the faster and cheaper route, notwithstanding that it looks more expensive on day one.

Step 5: Summons to judgment

Where the debt falls within the Magistrate’s Court monetary jurisdiction, that is where it belongs. High Court is available for larger claims but carries higher costs.

The sequence is familiar: summons is issued and served by the sheriff; the owner has 10 court days to enter appearance to defend. Most levy matters are undefended, because there is rarely a real defence to a properly raised levy. Where no appearance is entered, the body corporate applies for default judgment.

Judgment gives you two things: an enforceable debt, and a credit bureau listing that will follow the owner into every future credit application they make.

Step 6: Enforcement

Judgment is not payment. Enforcement is where schemes either recover or quietly write the matter off.

Warrant of execution against movables. The sheriff attaches and sells the owner’s movable property. Often symbolic in value, occasionally decisive in effect.

Emolument attachment order. If the owner is employed, an order under section 65J of the Magistrates’ Courts Act attaches a portion of their salary at source. Since University of Stellenbosch Legal Aid Clinic v Minister of Justice and Correctional Services [2016] ZACC 32 this requires judicial authorisation, a court must be satisfied the order is just and equitable and the amount appropriate, and total deductions across all such orders may not exceed 25% of basic salary. Slower than it used to be, but reliable once granted.

Section 65 financial enquiry. The owner is summoned to court to be examined on their means, and the court makes an installment order. Useful where employment is unclear.

Execution against the unit itself. Under section 66 of the Magistrates’ Courts Act, immovable property may be attached where movables are insufficient, but this requires a separate court application with judicial oversight of whether the sale is warranted. It is the last resort, and courts scrutinise it carefully where the property is the owner’s home.

The levy clearance certificate. The quiet one. The Registrar of Deeds cannot register transfer of a unit until the body corporate has certified that all moneys due to it have been paid or provided for. The scheme does not have to chase, it simply cannot be bypassed when the owner eventually sells. For schemes with patient trustees, this is often where old arrears finally come home.

What trustees may not do

Recovery has limits, and crossing them converts the scheme from creditor to respondent:

  • Do not disconnect water or electricity. Municipal services are not the body corporate’s to withhold as leverage, and doing so exposes the scheme to an urgent spoliation application it will lose, with costs.
  • Do not deny access to common property. Removing an owner’s access tag, blocking parking, or barring them from the pool because of arrears is unlawful.
  • Do not refuse to accept levy payments because the owner disputes part of the account.
  • Do not publish a defaulters list in the lift or on the notice board. That is a defamation and POPIA problem waiting to happen.
  • Do not let trustees act without a resolution. Recovery must be authorised.

The honest timeline

Trustees ask how long this takes. For an undefended levy matter handled through the Magistrate’s Court, our experience across levy and HOA collections is approximately six months from instruction to resolution. Defended matters take longer. CSOS routes frequently take longer still.

The variable that moves that number most is not the attorney. It is how long the scheme waited before instructing one.

Jonker Vorster Attorneys has acted for bodies corporate and homeowners associations since 2002 and handles more than 10,000 recovery matters a year nationally, including 450+ contested matters. The firm offers a No Success, No Fee model on qualifying levy collections. If your scheme is carrying arrears, you can read more about how the firm’s levy collection attorneys approach recovery.

This article is general information, not legal advice on any specific matter. Levy recovery turns on the facts of the scheme and the wording of its rules, take advice before acting.